Key takeaways
- Compare the best stall toys and boredom breakers for horses, from hay balls to treat feeders, to keep stalled horses occupied and engaged every day.
Time in a stall is part of life for many horses. Weather, injury rest, show schedules, and barn routines all create hours when a horse stands inside with little to do. Without occupation, restless horses may paw, weave, chew wood, or develop other habits that worry owners and can damage the stall. A well-chosen stall toy gives the horse something safe and interesting to nudge, lick, roll, and investigate.
Stall toys fall into clear groups. Hay balls slow forage intake, treat balls release feed as they roll, and scented play balls invite pushing and carrying. No toy replaces turnout and forage, but the right toy can make stalled hours calmer. This guide compares five options and covers safety checks that keep playtime sensible.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Quick answer
For most stalled horses, the Horsemen’s Pride Jolly Hay Ball is the best starting point, because it combines slow hay feeding with play and can hang or roll. The Shires Ball Feeder suits treat-motivated horses on the floor, while the apple scented Jolly Ball gives playful horses a durable ball with a handle for grabbing, carrying, and nudging around the stall or paddock.
1. Horsemen’s Pride Jolly Hay Ball Stall Toy
The Horsemen’s Pride Jolly Hay Ball is an 8-inch stall toy designed to hold hay and small treats. Openings around the ball let a horse pull at hay strands gradually, turning a small amount of forage into a longer activity. Pieces of carrot or apple can be tucked inside with the hay for added interest, encouraging the horse to roll, nudge, and reposition the ball to reach the contents.
The ball can hang or rest on the floor. Hanging adds movement, because it swings away as the horse works at it. On the floor, it rolls and invites nudging. The plastic construction wipes clean, and the compact size fits most stalls without blocking feeding areas.
This is a strong first toy for owners new to enrichment. It uses hay the horse already eats, so the reward is familiar forage rather than rich treats. Supervision during the first sessions is wise, to confirm the horse interacts calmly and the hanging height is correct.
2. Horsemen’s Pride 10-Inch Jolly Ball, Apple Scented
The Horsemen’s Pride 10-inch Jolly Ball in the apple scented version is a classic play ball for horses. It features an integrated handle that horses can grab, and that owners can use to hang the ball or carry it between stall and paddock. The ball is made from a durable, pliable material designed to resist punctures. If a horse bites or steps on it, the ball keeps its shape rather than deflating, which extends its working life in a busy barn.
The light apple scent adds interest without food. Horses that mouth objects often take to the handle quickly, shaking and tossing the ball. Hanging it keeps it off the bedding and creates a moving target, while in a paddock it works as a ground toy for nudging.
The 10-inch diameter suits most horses and large ponies. As a non-food toy, the Jolly Ball avoids extra calories entirely, which suits horses on restricted diets that still need occupation.
3. Horsemen’s Pride 14-Inch Jolly Tug Horse Toy
The Horsemen’s Pride Jolly Tug takes a different approach. It places a 14-inch Jolly Ball inside a tough Cordura nylon cover with handles, creating a tug and carry toy for horses that like to grab, pull, and shake. The cover adds grip and protects the inner ball, and it can be removed for washing, which helps in muddy seasons when stall and paddock toys get dirty quickly.
This toy suits bold, playful horses that lose interest in a plain ball. The handles give multiple grabbing points, and the larger size suits bigger horses. Used in a paddock or large stall, it encourages movement and investigation.
The Jolly Tug needs more management than a simple ball. Check stitching regularly, remove it if the fabric tears, and store it dry. It suits supervised play in roomy spaces better than overnight use in a small stall. For the right horse, it offers engagement plain balls rarely match.
4. Shires Ball Feeder Stable Toy
The Shires Ball Feeder is a treat-dispensing ball that rewards movement. The 9-inch ball holds small treats or pieces of feed, which drop out gradually as the horse rolls the ball with its nose or hoof. The design encourages slow, repeated nudging rather than quick eating, stretching a small handful of treats into a longer activity on the stall floor or in a paddock.
The feeder works best on a level surface where it can roll freely. Clearing a corner of deep bedding helps it move and keeps treats from getting lost. The plastic body is sturdy and easy to wash, and filling is simple. The release rate suits small, dry treats best.
This style fits food-motivated horses well, and most learn the game within one session. Owners managing weight should count ball treats in the daily ration and choose low-sugar options. Used in rotation with non-food toys, it adds variety without constant snacking.
5. MHLLGN Hay Feeder Horse Treat Ball
The MHLLGN Hay Feeder is a large hay ball designed for hanging feeding and play. The ball holds hay and lets the horse pull strands through the openings as it moves, slowing intake and extending the time a small hay portion lasts. The hanging format keeps hay off the floor, which can reduce waste from hay being trampled into bedding, and the swinging motion adds a gentle challenge as the horse works.
This style suits horses that eat quickly and then stand idle. Slowing the same ration fills more time with grazing behavior. Check the hanging strap before each use, and hang the ball where the horse can reach comfortably without stretching upward.
Capacity is the main advantage. A larger ball takes a generous hay portion, so refilling happens less often during a long show day or stall rest. Introduce it gradually and keep fresh water nearby. For forage-focused enrichment at a larger scale, it is a practical choice.
How to choose
Start with the horse’s habits. A horse that licks and nibbles calmly often does well with a hay ball that rewards patience. A playful horse that picks up buckets and lead ropes will likely prefer a handled ball or tug toy it can grab and carry. A strongly food-motivated horse may focus best on a treat ball, where the reward is clear and the effort is steady. Matching the toy to the behavior already on display gives the best chance of regular use.
Next, consider food. Hay balls extend forage already in the diet. Treat balls add calories unless filled carefully. Non-food toys add no calories, making them the safest daily option for easy keepers. A rotation mixing food and non-food toys keeps interest high without overfeeding.
Size and space come next. Hanging toys should swing clear of walls and buckets, at a reachable height. Floor toys need level ground. Smooth plastic cleans easily, while fabric covers need washing time. Every new toy deserves watched first sessions and regular checks for damage.
Who should skip
Stall toys are not right for every situation. Horses that panic, strike at hanging objects, or become frustrated and aggressive with puzzle-style feeders should skip those formats, because a toy that raises stress defeats its purpose. In those cases, extra forage in a slow-feed net, more turnout when possible, and calm companionship are better tools, discussed with the barn manager or veterinarian.
Owners should also skip treat-dispensing toys for horses with certain dietary or dental issues unless a veterinarian approves the treats and the chewing involved. Horses prone to choke need careful management around any food-based toy. Very young foals should not use hanging toys with straps or ropes, and small toys sized for ponies should not be given to large horses that could bite off pieces. Finally, anyone hoping a toy will fix a serious stable vice should reconsider. Toys support a good routine. They do not replace turnout, forage, exercise, and social contact, and persistent weaving, cribbing, or aggression deserves professional advice rather than another purchase.
FAQ
How long should a stall toy stay in the stall each day?
Most horses do well with a toy available for a few hours at a time, rotated across the day or across the week. Constant access can reduce interest, and food-based toys should be removed once empty. Regular rotation between two or three toys keeps each one feeling fresh and engaging.
Are hanging stall toys safe to leave unattended?
Hanging toys are widely used, but safe setup matters. Hang the toy so it swings freely away from walls, use sound straps or rope without loops a hoof or jaw could catch, and check fittings daily. Watching the first sessions and removing damaged items promptly keeps hanging toys a sensible option for most horses.
What treats work best in a treat ball feeder?
Small, dry, firm treats or pieces of the regular ration work best, because they release gradually and do not clog the openings or spoil inside the ball. Sticky or moist treats can block the holes and make cleaning harder. Counting ball treats within the daily ration helps manage weight and sugar intake.
How should stall toys be cleaned?
Plastic balls and feeders can be washed with warm water and a mild soap, rinsed well, and dried before refilling. Fabric covers should be washed according to the maker guidance and dried fully to prevent odor. Cleaning food toys after each use and play toys weekly keeps them hygienic in the barn environment.
Final verdict
The Horsemen’s Pride Jolly Hay Ball earns the top recommendation for its simple, forage-based approach that fits almost any feeding program. The apple scented Jolly Ball is the best non-food play option, durable and easy to hang or carry. The Jolly Tug serves bold horses that love to grab and shake, while the Shires Ball Feeder rewards food-motivated horses with steady treat release. The MHLLGN Hay Feeder covers larger hay portions for long stalled days. Rotating two or three of these toys, with regular safety checks, gives stalled horses varied, calm occupation throughout the week.
More from Amazon
Programs that pair well with the guide above. Offers and eligibility are set by Amazon and may change.
Set up recurring deliveries of everyday items on eligible products. Terms and savings are set by Amazon.
Explore Subscribe & SaveFree shipping on eligible items, Prime Video and more. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.
Start a Prime free trialAudiobooks and podcasts to listen to on the go. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.
Try Audible freeRead from a large library of eBooks and audiobooks on any device. Check Amazon for current plans.
Explore Kindle UnlimitedAs an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

Write Your Review
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!